Alisan Lohan-Conway Properties
salesrentalslist propertyproperty inquiryreal estate infomartha's vineyardcontact us
Island Wide Listings
↑ Click or tap to view or enlarge all 48 photos

EDGARTOWN

109 School Street, Edgartown, MA 02539

Single Family Residence
Lot Size: 0.17 Acres / 7,405 sq.ft.
$3,800,000.00
Listed: 18th September, 2023
Listed Price: $3,990,000
Contingent: 5th March, 2024
Offer to Purchase: 5th March, 2024
Purchase and Sale: 8th March, 2024
Sold: ↓ 9th April, 2024 for $3,800,000
LINK ID: 41017
STATUS: SOLD
Bedrooms: 6
Baths: 4
Rooms: 14
Living Space: 3193
Acreage: 0.1700
Water Frontage: None

TO INQUIRE ABOUT THIS LISTING CLICK HERE

Outdoor Spaces: Deck, Garden, Beach Access - Public, Patio, Porch
Features: Central Alarm/C, Irrigation, Outdoor Shower
Year Built: 1890
Year Renovated: 2018
Second Dwelling: None
Zoning: RES
Water: Town
Sewer: Twn
Lead Paint: Unknown
Heat: OFHW
Fireplaces: Two - 1 wood burning
Yard Type: Private with lush plantings, flowering trees and seasonal gardens.
Flooring: Restored as well as new wood floors
Stove: Thermador ® 6 burner
Washer: Yes
TV: Cable

DESCRIPTION

Captain’s Quarters - Sitting up tall and proud at the crest of School Street! This iconic Edgartown village property has a lot to boast about. Surrounded by superb and historic architecture, the preserved town setting provides unmatched amenities. Nearby shopping, eateries, harbor activities, as well as Katama and stunning south shore beaches. The historic six-bedroom home has been thoughtfully restored and beautifully transformed. With design concepts, stylish renovations, upgraded systems, and rooms that multitask with ease – it all adds up to an appealing package. Serviced by town water and grandfathered with a six bedroom town sewer flow. Attached garage plus on-site parking for multiple vehicles. Side access through the gated arbor leads to the outdoor shower, private back yard with patio, and a useful shed too!

FIRST FLOOR DESCRIPTION
Front to back; step inside this vintage charmer to a welcoming foyer with front staircase up to the left and a parlor/library to the right. Wide open living/dining room spans the width of the structure, complete with a china/butlers closet and wood burning fireplace. Heart of the home design combines an ample, fully equipped gourmet eat-in kitchen with a comfortable living space, gas fireplace, and access to side parking. Rear of the house has a third living room with sliders to the garden beyond, a beautifully crafted staircase, laundry room, full bathroom - and access to both garage and back yard.

SECOND FLOOR DESCRIPTION
Access is easy with two staircases leading to six bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms. Middle south facing bedroom enjoys a sunny balcony. Rear primary suite includes a dressing room and exterior deck and staircase to the back yard below.

BASEMENT DESCRIPTION
Partial with bulk head access - houses mechanicals dehumidifier.

OTHER BUILDINGS
Useful free standing shed anchors the corner of the private back yard.

SECOND DWELLING
None

PARKING
Convenient side on-site parking + garage

Martha's Vineyard - Island Wide Listings - Updated 1st of November, 2026
©2026 LINK, All Rights Reserved
Not responsible for misinformation or typographical errors. Prices are subject to change without notice.
 

Home | Martha's Vineyard Sales | Martha's Vineyard Rentals | List with Us | Property Inquiry | Real Estate Info | Martha's Vineyard | Contact Us

 

ALISAN LOHAN-CONWAY PROPERTIES MARTHA'S VINEYARD
Martha's Vineyard Real Estate Sales and Rentals

PO Box 2670, Edgartown, MA 02539
Phone: 508.627.1858 Fax: 508.696.7648

THE INFORMATION CONTAINED ON THIS WEBSITE IS DEEMED RELIABLE BUT NOT GUARANTEED

© 2026 Alisan Lohan-Conway Properties. All Rights Reserved.
Original content created by Alisan Lohan-Conway Properties, together with subsequent custom website modifications, design enhancements, functionality and presentation, is the property of Alisan Lohan-Conway Properties.
Third-party listing data, images, mapping and other credited materials remain the property of their respective owners.
Original website design by goffgrafix.com